95 Point Rated - Jeni Port Winepilot

"Beautiful, arresting aromatics and a rare delicacy; you just know you are in Watervale territory when you set upon that aroma, those flavours. Scents of citrus blossom, lemon zest, lime sorbet and spring flowers with a touch of lantana bring not only a sense of place but grape variety. The ’23 vintage looks to be another excellent year, making it three in a row for Clare Riesling, joining the outstanding ’21 and ’22. Not quite as seamless as its ’23 sibling but give it time. This youngster is still very much working at getting it together. There’s a clean, brisk acidity that’s tart and green apple crunchy. It drives the wine bringing in its wake lime cordial, pink grapefruit, ginger spice, citrus zest and a cool slate, wet stone tang. So pure, so good.” 

95 Point Rated - Steve Leszczynski Q Wine Reviews

"Pretty as ever, the O'Leary Walker Watervale Riesling is always an aromatic beauty. Clare Riesling has been smashing in in recent years and this release exemplifies that once again. White field flowers, citrus flowers, green apple skin, and lime zest come running at speed. A starburst of fruit sizzles in the mouth with citrus zest and juice front and centre. Zippy acidity with a green apple crunch for the win and a super fine cinnamon/ginger spice continue to elevate the pleasure factor. Yes, fill my bucket, please. Drink now and embrace the freshness." 

94 Point Rated - Huon Hooke The Real Review

"Very light colour and a reserved, shy, but refined and delicately scented lime/mandarin bouquet, with background mineral and floral touches. It’s delicate and refreshing to taste, not overly dry/austere but refreshing and clean at the finish. Dried flower heads and slaty minerals. Delicious and very appetising." 

 94 Point Rated - Ken Gargett Winepilot

"Seems 2023 makes it is a hattrick of great vintages in the Clare for Riesling. This bottle of joy is from a classic Watervale vineyard with a westerly aspect, the fruit is destemmed, crushed and gently pressed. The free run juice is settled and then fermented over the best part of two weeks. A very pale green/gold with a powerful and concentrated nose offering florals, minerals, wet slate, chalk and limes. Powerful but refined at all stages. Excellent length and a softly pleasing texture, this has a fine line of acidity. The palate offers a lovely lingering lemon pie note right at the finish. Drink over the next eight to twelve years, but it will certainly go for at least two decades, well cellared. Two things are certain. This will continue to improve and it is criminally underpriced (although long may it remain so for all us Riesling fans)." 

94 Point Rated - Angus Hughson Winepilot

"There is serious power and focus to be found in this 2023 Watervale Riesling with its tightly coiled stony, pithy, aromas with hints of dried flowers. Fabulous texture and intensity to follow, with freshly squeezed citrus flavours enhanced by granitic minerality that hold strong right through on a lengthy, acid-driven finish. An excellent vintage for this label." 

93 Point Rated - James Halliday Halliday Wine Companion

"This wine is usually the junior partner to its Polish Hill River sibling, but it comes up close with the acidity perfectly balanced through the long finish." 

93 Point Rated Campbell Mattinson The Wine Front

“Intensity, length and texture: there’s a combination for you. This tastes of lime, lime rind, bath salts and florals; it has a depth to it; there’s a banana-skin aspect to the aromatics but the palate dives deeper.” 

Silver Medal 

Halliday Wine Companion 2023