98 Point Rated - Ray Jordan Wine Pilot
"The structure of this Great Western sourced Shiraz follows previous years, but the fruit shows slightly more opulence and density. The colour is so deep and dark. The nose has a peppery, chalky minerality with spices and perfumed blue fruits. There is awesome power in the palate with a dense and concentrated profile of dark and smoothly plush blackberry fruits, some black olive, dark chocolate and a liberal dusting of spices. A little cordite on the finish and there you have it, another masterpiece from one of the great vineyards."

96+ Point Rated - Andrew Caillard MW
"Medium deep crimson. Beautifully intense and pure black cherry, black berry, mulberry star anise, hint black pepper aromas with underlying savoury notes. An inky deep palate with supple black cherry, blackberry fruits, animated fine chalky tannins, and roasted chestnut, ginger, vanilla oak notes. Finishes gravelly firm with persistent juicy fruits and fresh linear acidity. Still in elemental phase but generous and claret-like with superb richness, density and torque. Should develop very well. A classic central-Victorian Shiraz."

97 Point Rated - Huon Hooke The Real Review
"Very deep, youthful purple/red colour, with an expressive pepper-spice and graphite, earthy, ironstone bouquet. Very complex and multi-faceted in spite of its youth. The wine is very full-bodied, concentrated yet beautifully balanced, with ample fine, supple, yet persuasive tannins that bring an appetising dryness to the middle and end-palate. Richness, concentration, and impossible elegance into the bargain. A great shiraz. (Aged in small and large format French oak)."

95 Point Rated - Jeni Port Halliday Wine Companion
"Fermentation in small-batch open fermenters. Matured 14 months in small- and large-format French oak. Even in its youth, St. Peters brings a sense of poise and elegance. The '19 has an added degree of refinement, oak seems more measured than in the past, the fruit more composed. The vintage rates highly with winemakers in the region. Restrained aromas of earthy spice, plums, blackberries and a hint of bay leaf. Smooth and subtle in the mouth – it's early days – with depth."

93 Point Rated – Mike Bennie The Wine Front
"“Exceptional Vineyard” thunders the label. Indeed! Dark, brooding black berry fruit characters, white pepper dusted liberally, faint eucalyptus, green herb, roast meats. Authority in scent! Huge. Exciting. Sweet berry flavours, a late kick of savoury-meaty character, big presence in the palate, spreads wide, soft, with a web of fine, feathery slightly smoky-flinty tannins. More muscle. A distinct, bolder expression of St Peters here, not in the pedigree of recent releases, but showcasing the year, perhaps."